Much is written about Cash Bundren, the carpenter in William Faulkner's As I Lay Dying. While most essays focus on Cash's nature and function within the novel, occasional articles also discuss the significance of Cash's tools. For example, Michael Hardin, in "Freud's Family: The Journey to Bury the Death Drive in Faulkner's As I Lay Dying," notes that "[t]ools are often associated with male sexuality and the phallus because they represent the artisan's (pro)creative capabilities;" therefore, the loss of Cash's tools in the river crossing represents his symbolic castration (98). In his essay "Faulkner's As I Lay Dying," Tim Poland posits that Cash's "entire identity is located in the fact that he is a carpenter," and that "[h]is sole means of expression is through his carpenter skills" (118; 119). Poland notes that when Cash loses his tools to the flooding river, he simultaneously loses consciousness and the ability to speak. Thus, Poland links the loss of Cash's tools to the "submersion of Cash's selfhood" (119). As Poland observes, it is not until the tools are found that Cash regains both consciousness and speech (119).
That the tools function as more than just literal implements is also implied by the deliberate manner in which Cash regards and tends them. H. H. Siegele, in his book Carpenters' Tools: Their Care and Maintenance, discusses how tools become anthropomorphized in the hands and mind of an efficient and fastidious carpenter:
A carpenter should take such care of his tools, that they will seem like intimate friends;
which is to say, that if a tool is properly cared for, it will always be on friendly terms with the
man who uses it. (36)
In Cash, we see such a careful carpenter. After days of crafting his dying mother Addie's coffin and working outdoors throughout a rainy night to complete his task, Cash takes the time to tend his tools.Although he must be psychologically drained and physically exhausted, Cash "gathers his tools and wipes them on a cloth carefully and puts them into the box" (Faulkner 80). Later, during the family's trip to bury Addie, as he begins guiding the wagon across the swollen river, Cash "lifts his box of tools and wedges it forward under the seat," thus commencing the dangerous crossing with "his arm braced back against Addie and his tools" (147; 149). Cash thereby demonstrates the same concern for his tools as for his mother's remains in the coffin he had built to protect them.
The people surrounding him recognize and respect the importance to Cash of his tools. After the disastrous crossing, Vernon and Jewel go to great lengths to retrieve Cash's tools, then lay the tools next to the injured carpenter in an attempt to revive and reassure him (163). As the family sets off to Armstid's, Cash tries to speak, not to complain about his injuries or to inquire about the family's situation, but to ask about his tools (181). To calm Cash, "Vernon got them [the tools] and put them into the wagon. Dewey Dell lifted Cash's head so he could see" (181). Once at Armstid's, Cash's sole concern -- upon regaining consciousness after his leg is painfully set -- is his tools. Again, to comfort Cash, Darl brings the tools into the room and places them under the bed "where he [Cash] could reach his hand and touch them when he felt better" (186). Finally, Cash's tools are laid next to him in the wagon as a source of solace when the family resumes their journey to Jefferson (191).
Cash possesses a total of nine tools: adze, auger, chalk-line, hammer, plane, rule, square, saw, and saw set. Of these, Cash takes all but the adze and auger on the journey to bury Addie. Accordingly, seven tools accompany the seven Bundrens on their trip. All seven tools are briefly lost in the flooded river, which also nearly claims Addie's corpse; only six are recovered, corresponding to the six living members of the Bundren family. These parallels suggest that the tools serve a richer figural purpose in AILD than just as symbols of Cash's consciousness, power of speech, or sexuality. A careful look at the attributes and functions of the seven tools in Cash's tool box reveals a relationship between each tool and a corresponding member of the Bundren family.1
Often, parts of tools -- themselves extensions of the human body -- are given names that correspond to various parts of the anatomy. Where pertinent, such connections will be examined in this essay.Furthermore, while the basic nature and use of the tools found in Cash's tool box have remained the same since AILD was written over 70 years ago, improvements and innovations have been made to some of the tools mentioned. Therefore, the tools discussed here are, as best can be determined, of the type used during the 1920s, when the primary action of the novel occurs. This consideration is important in exploring the possible correlation between the tools in Cash's tool box and the individual members of the Bundren family.
The square is a tool used most often for determining right angles (Brown 187). It is also employed to produce a straight line for cutting off the end of a board (Hjorth 24). One type of square frequently used by carpenters during the time frame of present action in AILD is the try square. The try square is made up of a "steel blade set in a [. . .] wood or metal handle exactly at a right angle," with the handle being shorter than the blade (Hibben 73). Try squares come in several sizes, with the blades of most of them marked in inches (Hjorth 24).
The text implies that Cash's square most likely is a try square. Cash's square fits into his tool box -- which is able to lie under the seat of the wagon and the bed at Armstid's -- indicating a relatively small tool. [In contrast, for example, a framing square would have been unwieldy, with its shortest length, the tongue, measuring fourteen inches (Hjorth 25)]. Also, when Cash is beveling one of the boards for Addie's coffin, instead of using a tool to check his angle, he planes the edge, then "squints along the plank" to determine the proper slant (Faulkner 79). This indicates that Cash's square is set at a rigid angle, unlike the sliding T-bevel, a "try-square adjustable to any angle," with which Cash could more accurately measure the bevel (Hjorth 61).
The try square, with its particular advantage of permitting precision when squaring material, resembles Cash, with his low tolerance for ambiguity and insistence upon accuracy. These traits are evident from Cash's earliest years. According to Jewel, "when [Cash] was a little boy," in an effort to please Addie, he interpreted literally her wish for fertilizer and took "the bread pan and brought it back from the barn full of dung" (Faulkner 14). Later, as an adult, when asked how far he fell from the church roof in an accident that broke his leg, Cash answers, "Twenty-eight foot, four and a half inches, about" (90).
To yield precise measurements, a line should be squared "on both sides and both edges" of the board being cut (25). In an analogous manner, Cash looks at all sides of an issue in an attempt to discern what is true and correct. For example, he examines the incident, and implications, of the barn burning at Armstid's from several points of view. Despite his own heroic efforts in constructing and salvaging the coffin, Cash "can almost believe [Darl] done right in a way" by setting fire to the barn in his effort to destroy the coffin with its contents and put an end to the family's torturous journey (233). Cash also notes that Jewel, in spite of being "too hard" on Darl, had a right to be upset about the attempt to incinerate the coffin because it was also "the value of [Jewel's] horse Darl tried to burn up" (233). Although Cash believes "it's a shame" that Darl will be locked up in an institution, he finally "reckon[s] nothing excuses setting fire to a man's barn and endangering his stock and destroying his property" (233).
Descriptions of Cash emphasize characteristics that are reminiscent of the square. When he is introduced, and throughout his construction of Addie's coffin, Cash is presented sawing boards. While sawing, his arm is held at an angle that strongly resembles the right angle of the square. Similarly, after he breaks his leg for the second time, his lower body will resemble the unequal blade and handle lengths of the square. As Doc Peabody notes, Cash will "have to limp around on one short leg for the balance of [his] life" (240). 2
The plane's primary function is to level out the surface of wood, and its uses include, among others, reducing in size a board that is "a little thicker than you want it," and smoothing the rough edges of a board that has been ripped, that is cut in width rather than in length (Hibben 64). In The Carpenter's Tool Chest, Thomas Hibben describes the plane as "much like a chisel set at a fixed angle in a block of wood or a steel frame" (63). It is most likely that Cash's plane had a wooden block, not a steel block that would surely sink, given Vernon's suggestion about the plane that "'It'll float'" when he and Jewel were determining what tool would help them find Cash's saw (Faulkner 161).
Even the simplest plane consists of at least three parts: the cutter, the wedge with which to hold and adjust the cutter, and the block in which the cutter and wedge rest (Wildung 34). Depending on its complexity, however, a plane may contain as many as 20 named parts, several of them adjustable (Siegele 33). Among these are the cap, toe, heel, and mouth; the bottom of the block of the plane (called the stock) is known as the sole (Siegele 33; Hibben 65).
Intricate in its design, the plane can be complicated to use, requiring precise adjustment to insure uniform trimming (Siegele 34). It is essential to properly regulate the amount of the cutting blade (cutter) that protrudes from the mouth of the plane; if the blade sticks out too far, it can gouge, and therefore damage, the wood (Hibben 65). In addition, when using the plane one must recognize the direction of the grain of the wood being processed (Hjorth 55). As Herman Hjorth writes in Basic Woodworking Processes, "Planing against the grain makes the surface rough, while planing with the grain [. . .] makes it smooth" (Hjorth 55).
Like the plane in contact with wood, Darl demonstrates the ability to rub either with or against the grain of other characters. As an example of the former, Darl's actions at his mother's deathbed help to restore Cora Tull's "faith in human nature" (24). Cora even maintains that Darl "was touched by God Himself" (167). Although Cora's interpretation of Darl's behavior is later ironized, it demonstrates his ability to impress someone favorably, also reflected in Cora's daughter Eula's attraction to Darl (9).
On the other hand, his interactions with Dewey Dell and Jewel reveal his facility for alienating others, and it is here that his mouth gets him in trouble. Darl torments Dewey Dell about the "bad luck" of her pregnancy, and taunts her with his insight that Dewey Dell "'want[s] [Addie] to die so [she] can get to town'" for an abortion (39; 40). He further upsets Dewey Dell by refusing to disclose whether he plans to tell Anse about her pregnancy or to kill her lover, Lafe, for impregnating her (40).
Similarly, Darl torments Jewel with references to Addie's impending death, asking "'do you know that Addie Bundren is going to die? Addie Bundren is going to die?'" (40). Darl continues to irritate and provoke Jewel by alluding to Jewel's questionable parentage with statements such as "'Jewel . . . whose son are you?'" and "'who was your father, Jewel?'" (212). Like the plane whose blade has been improperly set, in these instances Darl's words cut too deep, causing Dewey Dell and Jewel to retaliate: Dewey Dell informs Gillespie that Darl started the barn fire, and Jewel attacks Darl, then helps restrain him for the authorities (237).
Like the complex plane, Darl is the most sophisticated member of the Bundren family. He is certainly the most worldly, as he is seemingly the only family member that has been outside the confines of Yoknapatawpha County. Perhaps because of his exposure to the greater world, Darl is able to relay events in poetic language, indicating his artistic soul (sole). For example, notice the internal rhyme when he muses, "How often have I lain beneath rain on a strange roof, thinking of home" (italics mine) (Faulkner 81). In a beautifully alliterative passage, Darl recounts, "The lantern sits on a stump. [. . .] its cracked chimney smeared on one side with a soaring smudge of soot, it sheds a feeble and sultry glare [. . .]" (75).
Accordingly, it is his voice that presents the "tableau" of Jewel and his horse, "savage in the sun" (12). And his description of "the square squat shape of the coffin on the sawhorses like a cubistic bug" speaks to his probable exposure to paintings by Pablo Picasso and Georges Braque when he was "in France at the war" (219; 254).
Additional examples of Darl's multi-dimensional character are woven throughout the text, reinforcing his connection to the intricate plane. One such trait is revealed in his uncanny ability to relate incidents at which he is not present, such as Addie's deathbed scene and Cash's completion of Addie's coffin (47-52; 75-80). In addition, Hamlet-like, Darl contemplates the enigmatic nature of being as he ruminates before sleeping: "And before you are emptied for sleep, what are you. And when you are emptied for sleep, you are not. And when you are filled with sleep, you never were. I dont know what I am. I dont know if I am or not" (80).
Finally, the reader becomes acutely aware of Darl's multi-faceted nature when he finally suffers a mental breakdown and his mind fragments into more than one personality (253). Like an inexperienced carpenter who does not understand how to properly adjust his plane, Darl has lost the ability to maintain his sanity.
According to Siegele, the hammer is, essentially, a tool used "for striking blows" (63). The carpenter uses it most often to drive nails "through one piece of wood into another" (Hibben 52). The hammer consists of a head, made of iron or steel, and the handle, commonly made of wood (52).
It is likely that Cash's hammer is a carpenter's hammer, or claw hammer, whose head incorporates a slightly rounded face with which the nails are pounded (52). Opposite the face is the peen, fashioned like a claw, with which nails can be extracted (Hjorth 186). This particular type of "bell-faced" carpenter's hammer prevents the wood from being indented or scarred when the nail is pounded flat to the wood (Hjorth 186; Hibben 52). In addition to the face and claw, the head of the hammer also contains the sleeve and house (or eye) into which the handle fits; the neck, which connects the sleeve to the head; and the poll, the flat surface between the face and the claw (Siegele 63).
Siegele suggests that "the hammer should be placed first when making a list of carpenter's tools" (63). In the Bundren family, Jewel, though not Addie's firstborn child, is her favorite. As Darl relates, "Ma always whipped him and petted him more" (Faulkner 18). Beginning with this simple correlation, we can associate the hammer with Jewel.
Of the tools in the carpenter's box, the hammer, according to Siegele, is one of the hardest working in that it "has the widest field of usefulness" (63). In like manner, Jewel demonstrates the willingness and ability to do many kinds of work. As Cora Tull recounts, "Jewel [was] always doing something that made him some money" (Faulkner 24). Jewel's secretive efforts clearing forty acres "single handed[ly]" to earn his horse indicate that he does not shy away from hard labor (135).
Jewel also exhibits physical characteristics that evoke images of the hammer. The wooden handle of the hammer is proportionately larger than the head, depending on the type of hammer. Thus, the hammer is primarily composed of wood. Appropriately, Jewel recognizes that of all the tools in Cash's box, the "'[h]ammer's got the most wood in it'" (161). Like the hammer, Jewel is repeatedly described as being composed of wood. He has "pale eyes like wood set into his wooden face" and walks "with the rigid gravity of a cigar store Indian" (4). Jewel is "wooden-backed, wooden-faced," and "sits on his horse like they were both made out of wood" (95; 122). After his horse is sold, Jewel rides on the wheel of the wagon into Jefferson "as though carved squatting out of the lean wood" (231). Additionally, his strength echoes the iron and wooden strength of the hammer. As the coffin is being moved from the house, "Jewel carries the entire front end [of the coffin] alone" (98). Later, "he upends the coffin and slides it single-handed from the saw-horses" (222).
Occasionally, the handle of the hammer shrinks and becomes loose within the sleeve. If this occurs and is not corrected, the inattentive carpenter may strike a blow and have the head of his hammer, quite literally, fly off the handle. People also fly off the handle, usually in anger. For Jewel, flying off the handle is habitual, so much so that virtually all his speech, and much of his action, is peppered with profanity and marked by fury. To his horse, he is overheard "cursing" with "obscene ferocity" and speaking "in a whisper of obscene caress" (12; 183). When he talks to other characters, "Goddamn you" seems to be his favorite retort, no matter what the stimulus. One can understand his angry rejoinder of "'Goddamn you. [. . .] Goddamn you'" to Darl's taunting about Addie's death (94), but Jewel's response of "'You go to hell [. . .] Goddamn you"' to Cash's suggestions about crossing the raging river seems unwarranted (146). His volatile nature almost causes a tragedy when he attempts to strike a knife-carrying man at whom he swears while on the road to Jefferson (229).
Jewel's recurrent pattern of striking blows is also reminiscent of the hammer's function. It is difficult not to feel sorry for his beloved horse as Jewel "strikes him across the face with his fist," "hammer[s] its head with his fist," and "strikes it upon the face with the back of the curry-comb" (13; 149; 183). Later, Armstid notes that Jewel, frustrated at being unable to move the wagon by himself, appears to be "fixing to beat out the back end of the shed" (188). Occasionally, Jewel's hammering is productive, such as when he three times strikes the wall of the burning barn with a stool, creating an opening that allows a cow to escape the fire (221). But, for the most part, Jewel's blows, like those of the bell-faced hammer, leave no lasting impression.
The carpenter frequently needs to mark a straight line longer than the straight edge of a square will allow. One way to accomplish this is by using a string or cord rubbed with a cake of blue chalk, known as the chalk-line (Hibben 72).
To use the chalk-line, the carpenter anchors one end of the string with, for example, a nail, to the point at which he wishes to mark one end of the material. Then, holding the other end of the string taut, he rubs the string with the cake of blue chalk (72). Both ends of the string are then secured so that the string rests above the "imaginary line" on the material to be marked (Siegele 20). The string is then snapped, leaving a distinct line on the material (20).
The chalk-line is the only tool in Cash's box that requires two separate components in order to be used.Faulkner doesn't mention the blue chalk cake; however, Cash's chalk-line is called "the blue string," indicating that the line has been chalked (Faulkner 162). In fact, the chalk-line has been so infused (dare I say impregnated?) with chalk that even after being soaked in the river it still has the capacity to turn Jewel's fingers blue (162). Fittingly, the color-saturated chalk-line relates to the pregnant Dewey Dell, who conceived her illegitimate child after she, aptly, "picked on down the row" of cotton with Lafe (27).
In order to store the chalk-line in their tool box, many carpenters use a chalk-line reel around which they coil the chalk-line (Wildung 45). Faulkner, however, does not indicate that Cash has such a device. Cash most likely winds up the chalk-line into a ball around itself. Correspondingly, Dewey Dell is wrapped up in the dilemma of her pregnancy. Her self-absorption is such that, as Darl suggests, she secretly yearns for Addie's death so that she can go to town to seek an abortion before her condition shows (40).
Like the string accompanied by the chalk, Dewey Dell is also virtually always in the company of someone else. When we first see her, she is tending to Addie, surrounded by the Tull women (9). Once Addie dies, Dewey Dell becomes responsible for her younger brother Vardaman, who is, therefore, her frequent companion. Dewey Dell sleeps with Vardaman, takes him with her to meet MacGowan, and, arguably, even masturbates when Vardaman is hidden nearby (215; 248; 62). More significantly, Dewey Dell is physically linked by an umbilical cord to the fetus she is carrying. Since this physical connection is not severed by an abortion, the emotional ties of motherhood and the responsibilities of parenthood seem likely to link Dewey Dell with her child for many years to come.
Furthermore, except for her plan to transport her Sunday clothes in a package disguised as Cora Tull's cakes, many of Dewey Dell's actions are prompted by the influence of others, usually men. Both Anse and Peabody instruct her to fix supper on the evening of Addie's death (51). Later, at Samson's behest, she helps his wife Rachel prepare food and beds (116). Moreover, it is Lafe who provides Dewey Dell with the idea, information, money, and, presumably, encouragement to seek "something at the drug store" that will end her pregnancy (202).
Finally, Dewey Dell is also easily "strung along." Lafe has done so, in both seducing her and inducing her to terminate the pregnancy. And McGowan, with just the barest deception, convinces her that he is a doctor, not a druggist's assistant, and that his "treatment" will be her cure (248).
A saw is the tool used by the carpenter to cut material (often wood) to the proper size. There are many types of saws; all consist of a flat steel blade -- comprised of a back, point, heel, and teeth -- attached at one end to a wooden handle (Siegele 24). To cut the material, the blade, with the teeth on the bottom, is drawn through the wood in a back-and-forth motion.
A good all-around saw, and the one likely found in Cash's tool box, is the crosscut saw, designed with a handle that is bolted on, a flexible blade, and teeth bent and beveled at a specific angle so as to permit a smooth cut across the grain of the wood (Hjorth 39). The bent teeth also allow for a saw cut wider than the blade, thus preventing the saw blade from binding in the cut and the saw dust from gumming up the cut (Hibben 57).
Siegele ranks the saw "a close second" to the hammer in importance among a carpenter's tools (24). Analogously, it can be argued that Vardaman -- Addie's youngest -- appears to be his mother's second most favored child. In the moments before her death, Addie, surrounded by part of her family, gazes at Anse "without reproach, without anything at all," watches Cash "neither with censure nor approbation," and does not even look at Dewey Dell (47; 48). However, "all her failing life appears to drain into her eyes, urgent, irremediable" as she searches, according to Dewey Dell, for Jewel (47). In like manner, just as she is dying, Addie "looks at Vardaman; her eyes, the life in them, rushing suddenly upon them; the two flames glare up for a steady instant" (48).
Vardaman, in spite of his youth, demonstrates a complex mind, at once fixed and malleable, reflecting both the ductility of the saw's blade and the rigidity of its wooden handle. In an effort to distract Vardaman from Addie's death, Dewey Dell tells him of the train set "behind the glass, red on the track" in the Jefferson shop window (66). Concerns about the train permeate Vardaman's thoughts throughout his journey. He frequently thinks of the train, "shining with waiting," and pesters Dewey Dell with his worry that one of the town boys has bought it (100; 102). His desire for it makes his "heart hurt" (216). Once in Jefferson, however, he readily yields to Dewey Dell's compensatory suggestion that he'd "rather have bananas" (252).
Similarly, his impressionable mind, in grief at the loss of his mother, conflates the image of Addie with the fish he has caught just prior to her death. In a related manner, Vardaman's mind is also susceptible to the suggestions of others. At Darl's intimation that Addie's corpse is speaking, Vardaman puts his ear to her coffin; he believes that he "can hear her. Only [he] cant tell what she is saying" (214).
While Vardaman, "with his round head and his eyes round," does not physically resemble the saw's straight edges and sharp lines, several examples of his phrasing in both thought and speech echo the repetitive, back-and-forth rhythm of the saw (47). For instance, after frightening off Peabody's horses, Vardaman cries to Cash, "'Durn him. I showed him. Durn him'" (56). And when Addie's coffin is rescued from the burning barn, Vardaman attempts to console Darl with the refrain, "'You needn't to cry, [. . .] Jewel got her out. You needn't to cry'" (225). Occasionally, too, like the saw teeth that become bent and then bind in the wood, Vardaman gets stuck in his phrasing. For example, when Jewel brings his horse home, Vardaman implores, "'Let me ride, Jewel. [. . .] Let me ride, Jewel. [. . .] Let me ride, Jewel'" (136).
As Cash is sawing the wood for Addie's coffin, "the saw in the board. [. . .] sounds like snoring" (9). This allusion to sleep further connects Vardaman to the saw. Vardaman is seen "laying asleep on the floor" after he bores the holes in Addie's coffin (73). Later, at Samson's, Vardaman is sleeping "in the trough in a empty stall" (117).
No matter what the project, the carpenter must have a means of measuring space and materials. To provide the most accurate measurement, the carpenter uses a rule. Rules come in many sizes, types, and materials, but the rule most likely in Cash's tool box is a folding rule, made of wood with jointed sections, so that it can easily fit in the tool box or the carpenter's pocket (Hjorth 23). A disadvantage of this type of rule appears over time with repeated use, however, as the joints become loose, causing measurements to be inexact (Siegele 116).
The angles and folds of the rule call to mind Anse's physical characteristics. Anse's "feet are badly splayed, his toes cramped and bent and warped," and his "wrists dangle out of his sleeves" (Faulkner 11; 31). But even from an early age, Anse more resembles the loosened joints of a well-used folding rule. As a young man, "he was beginning to hump [. . .] so that he looked already like a tall bird hunched in cold weather" (170). With age, his appearance only deteriorates; Darl notes that "[s]ince he lost his teeth his mouth collapses [. . .]" (17).
Like the worn rule that no longer gauges well, Anse is often perceived as faulty in his attempts to take the measure of situations. As Peabody muses, "I knew that if it had finally occurred to Anse himself that he needed one [a doctor], it was already too late" (42). More significantly, although Anse recognizes that "It's fixin up to rain," he allows Darl and Jewel to take the load of wood to town (18). This bad decision prepares the way for the series of disasters that follow.
That Anse is a poor "ruler" is also evident in the way he deals with his children. In one sense, he is an ineffective authoritarian. Jewel disregards Anse's order to "leave that horse" at home, and, similarly, both Cash and Dewey Dell insist on bringing their tools and "cakes," respectively, on the journey, thus "deliberate[ly] flouting" Anse's wishes (100; 101). In another sense, Anse is a poor father because he pursues his own needs at the expense of his children's. Intent on getting to Jefferson to buy false teeth and get a new wife, he selfishly and shamelessly pilfers money from "Cash's clothes" while Cash is unconscious, includes Jewel's hard-earned horse as part of the trade for the replacement mule team, and takes from Dewey Dell the ten dollars given her by Lafe for the abortion (190; 257).
The Saw Set
With use, saw teeth become dull and bent so that the saw no longer efficiently cuts wood; the teeth must then be sharpened. In conjunction with sharpening, the saw teeth must also be bent "slightly outward" in order to allow the saw cut to be wider than the thickness of the wood, thus preventing the saw from binding and buckling in the wood (Hjorth 4). This adjustment process that allows the saw to work properly is called setting, and the tool with which to bend and set the saw teeth is the saw set (4; 5).
There are various models, but most saw sets can be grouped into the categories of either plier-grip or pistol-grip saw sets (Siegele 30). It is likely that the saw set in Cash's tool box was of the plier-grip variety, a common type of that time (Hjorth 5). While the use of this type of saw set is somewhat awkward, in that manipulating it distorts the natural position of the hand and arm, the plier-grip saw set is not "cumbersome" in a tool box (Siegele 30).
That Addie functions as the counterpart to the saw set in the novel is evident even before she becomes a Bundren. In her role as teacher, Addie endeavors to keep her students in line, and even "look[s] forward to the times when they faulted, so [she] could whip them" (170). Addie also suggests adjustments to Anse while courting, indicating he needs a "hair cut" and that he should "hold [his] shoulders up" (171).
Once the Bundrens are married, it is Addie who keeps the family functioning in a relatively cohesive and controlled manner. As Tull notes, "She kept [Anse] at work for thirty-odd years" (33). And, as Anse admits, "no woman strove harder than Addie to make [the children] right" (38). But, like the saw set -- permanently lost in the river and thereafter no longer a part of Cash's tool box - Addie, at her death, no longer serves as the pivotal member of the Bundren family. With her passing, as noted in previous sections, the family unit weakens as members turn against one another.
Addie also possesses both personality traits and physical characteristics that allude to various aspects of the saw set. Like the inherent power of the saw set to bend metal, Addie's strong will is displayed in her determination to be buried in her home town. Although she lingers in a limbo between life and death for ten days, Anse recognizes that "Her mind is sot on [dying]" (italics mine) (43; 45). Later, Tull explains to his fellow mourners that Anse is taking Addie to Jefferson to be buried because "Her mind was set on it" (italics mine) (89). In addition, her "curled, gnarled" hands reflect the awkward position of the carpenter's hand as he uses the saw set (51).
William Faulkner, "handy with tools and experienced as a [. . .] handyman of sorts," personally performed some of the renovation work at his beloved Rowan Oak (Blotner 657). His understanding of tools and carpentry is also evident in his frequent use of carpenter's tools and skills as metaphors for different aspects of the craft of writing. For example, when asked, "Do you deliberately use symbolism in your works?" Faulkner responded: "The writer does not purposely use symbolism but does it instinctively. The writer is like a carpenter. When he needs a tool, he just leans back and gets a tool he thinks will work. He does not sit and think of which to use" (qtd. in Inge 166).
Did Faulkner "purposely" or "instinctively" correlate Cash's implements and the Bundren characters? The reader can never be sure. What is certain is that he reached into his tool box and gathered a collection of extraordinary tools with which to tell his tale, one which joins the talents of Faulkner the artisan with the genius of Faulkner the artist. 3
Blotner, Joseph. Faulkner: A Biography. Vol. 1.New York: Random House,1974.
Brown, Calvin S. A Glossary of Faulkner's South. New Haven: Yale UP,1976.
Faulkner, William. As I Lay Dying. New York: Vintage International,1990.
Hardin, Michael. "Freud's Family: The Journey to Bury the Death Drive in Faulkner's As I Lay Dying." Southern Studies 5.3-4 (1994) : 95-103.
Hibben, Thomas. The Carpenter's Tool Chest. Philadelphia: Lippincott,1933.
Hjorth, Herman. Basic Woodworking Processes. Milwaukee: Bruce,1935.
Inge, M. Thomas, ed. Conversations with William Faulkner. Jackson: UP of Mississippi,1999.
Poland, Tim. "Faulkner's As I Lay Dying." Explicator 49.2 (1991):118-20.
Siegele, H. H., Carpenters' Tools: Their Care and Maintenance. New York: Drake, 1971.
Wildung, Frank H. Woodworking Tools at Shelburn Museum. Burlington: Lane,1957.